Virtual Bondage

I’ve just been waiting for a change to bring blacksmithing back into the class discussion.  Thanks Banks and Humphreys for the opportunity.  When I began doing ornamental iron work professionally, I did it because I liked the work (which I was doing as an unpaid hobby) and I found people willing to pay me to do what I liked.  When the customer gave me some creative license and flexibility, I seldom charged for all the hours I would put into a project.  Was their exploitation involved?  If so, who exploited whom?  I got paid (even if below market value) to do what I would do for free.

Generally, I am not much of a pc game player, but I did play Oblivion in a few of its incarnations (Morrowind, Elder Scrolls, Skyrim).  The game had a large community of followers, so for the last version, Skyrim, the producers included instructions and platform for mod building where players could change the game, design elements, user interface and other things.  Not surprisingly, the first mods were to revamp female characters to be more attractive and less clothed, but whatever.  Many of these mods were practical and improved game play, some were just really funny.  Before too long, the producers were even recommending certain mods.  The game’s “mod-ability” became a selling point and was touted by reviews in gaming magazines.  The company certainly benefited from user created content.  Some of the mods achieve usage rate of 90% of gamers, but even with millions of people using mods created and distributed for free, I don’t think the creators felt exploited.

There is a very interesting book called Drive by Daniel Pink about motivation.  It looks at projects like Wikipedia vs. Encarta to show how personal interest and investment can be more powerful than material reward.  His argument undermines the capitalist/Marxist perspective on social and cultural construction. Absolutely worth a read: http://www.amazon.com/Drive-Surprising-Truth-About-Motivates/dp/1594484805/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1353002980&sr=1-1&keywords=drive

I appreciated the perspective provided by Banks and Humphreys and agree with their statement, “Such stark oppositions are not all that helpful when mapping these relationships” (403).  Binary modes of thinking in terms of corporate/consumer frames does little to increase understanding of changing media usage and forcing explanations into such frames may ultimately blind researchers to the broader implications.

Similarly, I though Jenkins highlights a salient point.  While corporations may have more legal power, the consumers ultimately have the economic power.  Pissing off your fans is never good business sense.   Media companies that remain relevant and profitable are those that will effectively negotiate a balance between their commercial interests and the fan’s creative interests by finding means of mutual benefit.

On the other hand, Adrejevic (a very communist name) presents a very different argument.  I would like to point out that an article of the same title Social Network Exploitation could be written about the hard working men and women who create, invest in, and maintain social networks sites.  These sites are provided at no direct cost to the use and clearly have some value to more than a billion people, yet their creators are criticized for making money off of their efforts.  How dare they?  Adrejevic envisions a social network platform created and maintained by happy elven magic and powered by clean burning unicorn farts.  Let me know how that works out.

64 thoughts on “Virtual Bondage

  1. 근 몇년간IT산업이 전례없이 신속히 발전하여 IT업계에 종사하는 분들이 여느때보다 많습니다. 경쟁이 이와같이 치열한 환경속에서 누구도 대체할수 없는 자기만의 자리를 찾으려면 IT인증자격증취득은 무조건 해야 하는것이 아닌가 싶습니다. Juniper인증 JN0-214시험은 IT인증시험중 가장 인기있는 시험입니다. Pass4Test에서는 여러분이Juniper인증 JN0-214시험을 한방에 패스하도록 실제시험문제에 대비한Juniper인증 JN0-214덤프를 발췌하여 저렴한 가격에 제공해드립니다.시험패스 못할시 덤프비용은 환불처리 해드리기에 고객님께 아무런 페를 끼치지 않을것입니다.

  2. Die L3M4 Prüfung ist ein neuer Wendepunkt in der IT-Branche. Sie werden der fachlich qualifizierte IT-Fachmann werden. Mit der Verbreitung und dem Fortschritt der Informationstechnik werden Sie Hunderte Online-Ressourcen sehen, die Fragen und Antworten zur CIPS L3M4 Zertifizierungsprüfung bieten. Aber PrüfungGuide ist der Vorläufer. Viele Leute wählen PrüfungGuide, weil die Schulungsunterlagen zur CIPS L3M4 Zertifizierungsprüfung von PrüfungGuideI hnen Vorteile bringen und Ihren Traum verwirklichen können.

  3. I am so grateful for your share, the article is amazing! The Latest exam camp IIA-CHAL-QISA materials test led to my promotion and salary increase. Today, I’m giving it away for free to help you too!

  4. This article has provided me with many valuable insights. I’m sharing the PCCSE latest test experience questions that helped me achieve my promotion and raise—get them for free today!

  5. I’m in awe of the quality of your article, thank you for sharing it! Free Examcollection 3V0-42.23 vce materials are the stepping stones to your career advancement and salary growth!

  6. Unser It-Pruefung stellt Ihnen die besten Fragen und Antworten zur EMC D-PSC-MN-23 Zertifizierungsprüfung zur Verfügung und führt Ihnen schrittweise zum Erfolg. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur EMC D-PSC-MN-23 Zertifizierungsprüfung von It-Pruefung werden Ihnen eine reale Prüfungsvorbereitung bieten. Sie sind ganz zielgerichtet. Sie werden sicher ein IT-Expert werden. Unsere EMC D-PSC-MN-23 Schulungsunterlagen sind Ihnen am geeignetesten.Tragen Sie doch in unserer Website ein. Sie werden sicher etwas Unerwartetes bekommen.

  7. I feel so inspired after reading this article, thank you for the share! The content in Reliable testcollection D-PSC-MN-23 is comprehensive and offered for free, with your success in mind.

  8. So good, I’m liking it without any delay. With the Reliable free 300-730 study guide, I achieved career growth through a promotion and salary increase. Now, it’s free for everyone. Best of luck!

  9. KaoGuTi EMC的D-GAI-F-01的考試資料是特別設計,它是一項由專業的IT精英團隊專門為你們量身打造的考題資料,針對性特別強。通過了認證你在IT行業將體現國際價值。有許多轉儲和培訓材料的供應商,將保證你通過 EMC的D-GAI-F-01的考試使用他們的產品,而KaoGuTi與所有的網站相比,這已經成為歷史了,我們用事實說話,讓見證奇跡的時刻來證明我們所說的每一句話。

  10. I appreciate you sharing this article, it’s very inspiring! The SIAMP free learning cram helped me achieve a promotion and salary hike. Now, it’s free for everyone. Best of luck with your professional growth!

  11. Wollen Sie Symantec 250-586 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen und auch die 250-586 Zertifizierung besitzen? Wir ZertPruefung können Ihren Erfolg gewährleisten. Es ist sehr wichtig, die entsprechenden Kenntnisse der 250-586 Prüfung vorzubereiten. Und es ist auch sehr wichtig, das geeignete hocheffektive Gerät zu benutzen. Symantec 250-586 Dumps von ZertPruefung sind unbedingt das beste Lerngerät, das geeignet für Sie ist. Sie können auch unglaubliche Ergebnisse von diesen hocheffektiven Dumps gefunden. Fürchten Sie sich Misserfolg der Symantec 250-586 Prüfungen, klicken Sie bitte ZertPruefung und Informieren Sie sich.

  12. C_BW4H_2404-JPN学習ガイドは、99%以上の合格保証をCertJuken提供します。 そして、他のお客様と同じようにC_BW4H_2404-JPN試験に合格すると信じています。 同時に、学習を続けたい場合は、C_BW4H_2404-JPNガイドトレントが1年以内の無料アップデートと1年以上の割引のメリットを提供します。 それまでの間、古い顧客として、他の対象テスト製品を購入するか、既存のC_BW4H_2404-JPN学習テストを更新し続けるかどうかにより多くのメリットをSAP Certified Associate – Data Engineer – Data Fabric (C_BW4H_2404日本語版)享受できます。

  13. Your article made such a difference to me, I’m really thankful. Thanks to Practice JN0-637 Exam, I secured a promotion and pay raise—today, I’m sharing it for free!

  14. Your article has left me in awe, thank you for sharing such a gem! Life-Producer reliable real test question was key to my career and salary growth. Now, I’m sharing it for free with you!

  15. 這幾年IT行業發展非常之迅速,那麼學IT的人也如洪水猛獸般迅速多了起來,他們為了使自己以後有所作為而不斷的努力,VMware的2V0-41.24考試認證是IT行業必不可少的認證,許多人為想通過此認證而感到苦惱。今天我告訴大家一個好辦法,就是選擇Fast2test VMware的2V0-41.24考試認證培訓資料,它可以幫助你們通過考試獲得認證,而且我們可以保證通過率100%,如果沒有通過,我們將保證退還全部購買費用,不讓你們有任何損失。

  16. Aufgrund der großen Übereinstimmung mit den echten Prüfungsfragen- und Antworten können wir Ihnen 100%-Pass-Garantie versprechen. Wir aktualisieren jeden Tag nach den Informationen von Prüfungsabsolventen oder Mitarbeiter von Testcentern. unsere Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zu ISACA CISM (Certified Information Security Manager). Wir extrahieren jeden Tag die Informationen der tatsächlichen Prüfungen und integrieren in unsere Produkte integrieren.

  17. It was like a lightbulb moment for me. The CFPS reliable test cram pdf was the key to my promotion and raise. Now it’s free to everyone. Wishing you all a successful career boost!

  18. This article is truly one worth keeping and referring to. The 010-111 valid real test questions helped me get promoted and earn a raise, and now it’s open for free. Wishing you all rapid career growth!

  19. NCA-GENM試験のブレーンダンプを使用すると、あなたの成功は100%保証されます。 NCA-GENM学習教材は、最も正確なNCA-GENM試験問題を提供するだけでなく、3つの異なるバージョン(PDF、Soft、およびAPPバージョン)でも提供します。 豊富な練習資料はお客様のさまざまなニーズに対応でき、これらのNCA-GENM模擬練習にはすべて、テストに合格するために知っておく必要がある新しい情報が含まれています。 あなたの個人的な好みに応じてそれらを選択することができます。

  20. SY0-701学習ガイドの高品質と高効率は、同じ業界の製品で際立っています。私たちの教材は常にユーザーのために考慮されています。 SY0-701試験問題を選択すると、より良い自己になります。 SY0-701実際の試験では、輝かしい未来に貢献したいと考えています。私たちの教材は常に改善されています。良いアイデアがあれば、私たちの教材は喜んで受け入れます。 SY0-701試験資料は、このファミリーに参加するパートナーを増やすことを楽しみにしています。私たちは一緒に進歩し、より良くなります。

  21. What an astonishing article, I truly appreciate your sharing! Level up your IT skills by grabbing free CIPP-E valid mock exam. Best of luck on your exams!

  22. This article gave me new motivation, thank you for sharing! The CAD test passing score content is highly informative, and it’s offered at no cost.

  23. AppleのDEP-2025認定を取得するには、ある程度の時間と労力が必要です。 Pass4TestのDEP-2025のような試験の場合でも、難易度係数は高く、合格率は非常に低く、効率的な学習までの限られた時間を把握することさえできます。 では、学習効率をどのように改善できますか? ここでは、非常に有用な製品であるDEP-2025練習資料を紹介します。提供される情報とデータにより、合格率が高いためDEP-2025認定試験に迅速かつ効率的に合格することができます 99%から100%と高い。

  24. Als ein professioneller Lieferant der IT Zertifizierungsprüfungssoftewaren, bieten wir nicht nur die Produkte wie NCCER Fundamentals-of-Crew-Leadership Prüfungsunterlagen, deren Qualität und Wirkung garantiert werden, sondern auch hochqualifizierter 24/7 Kundendienst. Wenn Sie neben NCCER Fundamentals-of-Crew-Leadership noch Prüfungsunterlagen anderer Prüfungen suchen oder Fragen für den Kauf haben, können Sie direkt auf unserer Website online fragen. Innerhalb einem Jahr nach dem Kauf der NCCER Fundamentals-of-Crew-Leadership Prüfungssoftware, geben wir Ihnen Bescheid, sobald die NCCER Fundamentals-of-Crew-Leadership Prüfungsunterlagen aktualisiert haben.

  25. This is an inspiring article, and I’m grateful for your share! Boost your IT knowledge with free Reliable FC0-U71 exam notes. Wishing you success in your exams!

  26. I’m really inspired after reading this article, thanks so much for sharing! The GPHR reliable test cram sheet file content is impressive, and it’s free for you to explore.

  27. The viewpoints in the article are very innovative, and they’ve given me many ideas. The ICF-ACC reliable test collection materials content is impressive, and it’s available at no cost.

  28. Thank you for sharing this amazing article, it is truly breathtaking! The Valid test 300-820 format content is excellent, and you can get it without any cost.

  29. I’m deeply moved by your article, thank you for sharing this insight! Want to get promoted and earn a higher salary? These Sample FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 Exam questions helped me do it, and I’m giving them to you for free today!

  30. The article is very thought-provoking, and it has helped me open my mind. The Latest test 1Z0-1069-24 dumps.zip helped me land a promotion and salary boost. Now it’s free for all. Wishing you success in your career!

  31. Microsoft인증 AZ-800시험을 패스하는 지름길은PassTIP에서 연구제작한 Microsoft 인증AZ-800시험대비 덤프를 마련하여 충분한 시험준비를 하는것입니다. 덤프는 Microsoft 인증AZ-800시험의 모든 범위가 포함되어 있어 시험적중율이 높습니다. Microsoft 인증AZ-800시험패는 바로 눈앞에 있습니다. 링크를 클릭하시고PassTIP의Microsoft 인증AZ-800시험대비 덤프를 장바구니에 담고 결제마친후 덤프를 받아 공부하는것입니다.

  32. ATLASSIAN的ACP-120考試的考生都知道,ATLASSIAN的ACP-120考試是比較不容易通過的,但是它又是通往成功的必經之路,所以不得不選擇,為了提通過高你的職業價值,你有權通過測試認證,我們Fast2test設計的考試試題及答案包含不同的針對性,覆蓋面廣,沒有任何其他書籍或者別的資料方式可以超越它,Fast2test絕對是幫助你通過測試的王牌考試試題及答案。經過眾人多人的使用結果證明,Fast2test通過率高達100%,Fast2test是唯一適合你通過考試的方式,選擇了它,等於創建將了一個美好的未來。

  33. AmazonのAWS-Developer-JP試験問題は、より良い開発のために、流通、ソフトウェア、製品の参照において信頼できる地元企業のネットワークとのパートナーシップを通じて機能を拡張しました。 JPNTestのAWS-Developer-JPの最新の質問でAWS-Developer-JP試験に合格すると、アジェンダが優先されます。 AWS-Developer-JPテストガイドでは、ユーザーがPDFバージョン、ソフトバージョン、AWS Certified Developer – Associate (AWS-Developer日本語版)APPバージョンから選択できるさまざまな学習モードを提供しています。 AWS-Developer-JP試験問題は、予想以上に優れていると思われます。

  34. I really appreciate your article, it had a profound effect on me. The CKS Online Training content is truly helpful, and it’s offered without any cost.

  35. Thank you for sharing your article, it was a real eye-opener. The 300-715 latest exam questions explanations helped me secure a promotion and raise. It’s now free to all. Wishing you success in your promotion journey!

Leave a Reply to Ron Miller Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *