Too Much Democracy

Politicians and pundits alike have lamented the increasing polarization in Congress.  Recent books and articles describe an increasingly divisive atmosphere in our nation’s capital that stretches back to the 1980s.  In addition to the anecdotal evidence offered in these books, recent studies have offered empirical evidence of increased partisan division.  Beyond documenting the rise of partisanship, several hypotheses have been suggested to explain this trend.  These explanations include redistricting efforts which produced more politically homogenous districts supporting one party over another and fewer competitive districts in which either party could win.  Others have argued the rise in partisanship is the result of a top down effort by party elites, or conversely, the trend is a bottom up phenomenon. However, studies of these explanations have failed to provide strong evidence to support them.

A possible influence on the increased polarization which has yet to be carefully examined is the role of media in this trend.  The rise in partisanship coincides with changes in traditional media coverage and the use of new sources of information and communication technology.  This paper reviews the evolution of communication technology and new media and its impact on the political arena in America and makes the argument that new media enables and supports the fragmentation of society by political ideology resulting in the rise of partisanship.  While new media can generally be considered to be internet based and mobile communication platforms, for the purposes of this paper, cable news networks will also be considered because their introduction marked a shift away from the traditional and fairly centrist broadcast news coverage.   Beginning in the early 1980’s, cable television provided directs access to Congressional proceedings, allowing voters to see first-hand and in real time what their representatives were doing and saying.  Research on the “CNN Effect” and the 24 hour news cycle strongly reveals the impact this change has had on foreign policy.   In the same decade, changes in FCC regulations allowed media outlets to provide political coverage with a specific bias without having to offer equal time for opposing views.  The result was that media consumers could select information sources which reflected their political ideology.

Technological advances in communication have also fostered individuals’ abilities to participate in the political process by increasing the ease with which voters can communicate with their representatives, as well as monitor the votes, finances, and other activities of elected officials.  These same technologies have allowed candidates to raise substantial campaign funds through the aggregation of small donor contributions to an extent not possible previously.

Research on the behavioral and attitudinal outcomes of media use highlights several important phenomena that ripple through the political process and have the tangible effect of polarizing our legislative bodies.  Well established theories of agenda-setting, framing, and cultivation applied to political activities shed new light on the overarching discourse and practice of politics in the past few decades.  Additionally, the dynamics of reinforcing spirals of media selection and personal attitudes offer valuable insight into the relationships between media, voter, and elected official.  The article concludes with a detailed description of how shifting news coverage and new communication technology fostered the growth of ideologically focused, non-collocated communities which circulated messages previously considered extreme or from the fringe. These messages were then carried through a complicated and self-reinforcing network to the national conscience.  This communication process developed concurrently and symbiotically with an increased dependence on ideologically connected individuals and small groups by candidates for financial support.  The end result is an escalating trend of partisanship and polarization in the American political system.

 

Selected References

 

Abramowitz, A. I. and Saunders, K.L. (2008). Is polarization a myth? The Journal of Politics, 70 (2),542-555

Gerbner, G., Gross, L., Morgan, M., Signorielli, N., & Shanahan, J. (2002). Growing up with television: Cultivation processes. In J. Bryant & D. Zillman (Eds.), Media effects: Advances in theory and research (pp. 43–68). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Fiorina, M.P., Abrams, S. A., & Pope, J.C. (2008).  Polarization in the American public: Misconceptions and misreadings. The Journal of Politics, 70 (2), 556-560.

McCombs, M., & Shaw, D. (1993). The evolution of agenda-setting research: Twenty-five years in the marketplace of ideas. Journal of Communication, 43(2), 58–67.

Scheufele, D. A., & Moy, P. (2000). Twenty-five years of the spiral of silence: A conceptual review and empirical outlook. International Journal of Public Opinion Research, 12, 3–28.

Schermer, C. (2010). Reinforcing spirals of negative affects and selective attention to advertising in political campaign. National Center of Competence in Research. Berne, Switzerland.

Slater, M. D. (2007). Reinforcing spirals: The mutual influence of media selectivity and media effects and their impact on individual behavior and social identity. Communication Theory, 17, 281-303.

71 thoughts on “Too Much Democracy

  1. The article “Too Much Democracy” explores the complexities of democratic participation in the digital age, questioning whether an overload of opinions dilutes effective governance. It raises important concerns about the balance between public voice and decision-making efficiency. For a deeper understanding of democracy’s digital challenges, I recommend exploring resources like ChatGPT at https://gptjp.net/, where free AI-powered insights are available.

  2. Thank you for your insightful article, it’s truly eye-catching. Free Online CIPP-US lab simulation to help you enhance your IT expertise. Best of luck on your exams!

  3. 만약Itcertkr를 선택하였다면 여러분은 반은 성공한 것입니다. 여러분은 아주 빠르게 안전하게 또 쉽게VMware 2V0-72.22인증시험 자격증을 취득하실 수 있습니다. 우리Itcertkr에서 제공되는 모든 덤프들은 모두 100%보장 도를 자랑하며 그리고 우리는 일년무료 업데이트를 제공합니다.

  4. No question, this content is getting a like. Here’s the Latest H19-308_V4.0 exam experience test that helped me get promoted and raise my salary. It’s free today—hope it helps you with your career goals!

  5. 안심하시고ExamPassdump 를 선택하게 하기 위하여, ExamPassdump에서는 이미SASInstitute A00-420인증시험의 일부 문제와 답을 사이트에 올려놨으니 체험해보실 수 있습니다. 그러면 저희한테 신뢰가 갈 것이며 또 망설임 없이 선택하게 될 것입니다. 저희 덤프로 여러분은 한번에 시험을 패스할 수 있으며 또 개인시간도 절약하고 무엇보다도 금전상으로 절약이 제일 크다고 봅니다. ExamPassdump는 여러분들한테 최고의SASInstitute A00-420문제와 답을 제공함으로 100%로의 보장 도를 자랑합니다, 여러분은SASInstitute A00-420인증시험의 패스로 IT업계여서도 또 직장에서도 한층 업그레이드되실 수 있습니다. 여러분의 미래는 더욱더 아름다울 것입니다.

  6. Straight to the like button—this is fantastic. Here’s the Simulations 71402X pdf test that helped me land my promotion and raise. It’s free today—good luck with your career progress!

  7. What a remarkable piece of writing, thank you for sharing this with us! Free Reliable test CFE questions answers study materials available now—good luck!

  8. This article is brilliant, and I’ve gained many insights from it. Here’s the FCP_FAZ_AN-7.4 free practice test that played a part in my promotion and salary increase, and it’s free for you today! Wishing you all the best in your career!

  9. JPNTestの専門家チームがISTQBのCTAL-TA認定試験に彼らの自分の経験と知識を利用して絶えなく研究し続けています。JPNTestが提供したISTQBのCTAL-TA試験問題と解答が真実の試験の練習問題と解答は最高の相似性があり、一年の無料オンラインの更新のサービスがあり、100%のパス率を保証して、もし試験に合格しないと、弊社は全額で返金いたします。

  10. Your article truly left me in awe, thank you for sharing! This is the CWT-101 reliable exam cram test that helped me with my career progression and salary increase, and it’s available to you for free today. Wishing you success in your career!

  11. After reading this article, I’ve gained a new perspective on how to look at the problem. Reliable test 1z0-1108-2 question and answer helped me get promoted and get a pay raise. Now, I’m sharing it with you for free today!

  12. Warum wählen viele Leute die Schulungsunterlagen zur Oracle 1z0-1127-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ITZert? Es gibt auch andere Websites, die Schulungsressourcen zur 1z0-1127-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung bietet. Unser ITZert stellt Ihnen die echten Prüfungsmaterialien zur Verfügung. Unser Eliteteam, Zertifizierungsexperten, Techniker und berühmte Linguisten bearbeiten die neueste Oracle 1z0-1127-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung. Deshalb klicken Sie ITZert Website, wenn Sie die Oracle 1z0-1127-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen wollen. Mit ITZert können Sie Ihren Traum Schritt für Schritt verwirklichen.

  13. This article is incredibly thought-provoking, I appreciate you sharing it! With the help of this C_ACT_2403 test notes, I earned a promotion and salary increase. Now I’m offering it for free. Wishing you all the best in your career!

  14. 성공을 위해 길을 찾고 실패를 위해 구실을 찾지 않는다는 말이 있습니다. Databricks인증 Databricks-Certified-Data-Analyst-Associate시험이 영어로 출제되어 시험패스가 너무 어렵다 혹은 회사다니느라 공부할 시간이 없다는 등등은 모두 공부하기싫은 구실에 불과합니다. ITDumpsKR의 Databricks인증 Databricks-Certified-Data-Analyst-Associate덤프만 마련하면 실패를 성공으로 바꿀수 있는 기적을 체험할수 있습니다.

  15. This article is truly awe-inspiring, thank you for sharing! Free Latest exam SK0-005 certification cost exam resources—wishing you all the best in your exams!

  16. ウェブサイトのページには、ACD301の実際のクイズに関する重要な情報、試験の名前とコード、更新時間、質問と回答の合計数、製品の特性とメリット、価格、クライアントへの割引が記載されています。 、ACD301トレーニング資料の詳細と保証、連絡方法、当社製品に関するクライアントの評価、および関連する試験。 ACD301本物のクイズを購入する前に、ウェブサイトのページが提供する情報を注意深く分析できます。

  17. Your article is so inspiring, thank you for sharing! The Real QSA_New_V4 testing environment platform offers detailed material at no cost, aimed at assisting you.

  18. Découvrez ChatGPT Français, le ChatGPT gratuit propulsé par les modèles o3-mini d’OpenAI. Profitez d’un accès illimité sans inscription pour explorer tout le potentiel de ChatGPT Français. Essayez-le dès maintenant et vivez l’expérience d’un ChatGPT gratuit au service de vos besoins en français ! Vous pouvez utiliser chatgpt gratuitement sur https://chatgpt-francais.com/

  19. NSE7_EFW-7.2ガイド資料の誤った情報を取得する心配はありません。個人の好みと予算の選択に応じて、ショッピングカートに参加するための適切な商品を選択します。 NSE7_EFW-7.2学習資料の3つの形式は、PDF、ソフトウェア/ PC、およびAPP /オンラインです。各形式には、明確な長所と短所があります。専門家によって作成された印刷可能なPDF形式があり、ダウンロードにアクセスできれば、いつでもどこでもNSE7_EFW-7.2トレーニングエンジンを学習できます。また、NSE7_EFW-7.2シミュレートされた実際の試験環境を備えたインストール可能なソフトウェアアプリケーションもあります。

  20. Your article was truly eye-catching and impressive, thank you! Free access to Test 1Z0-1084-25 questions and answers’s content is provided, hoping it will benefit your studies.

  21. Analyse très pertinente sur le rôle des médias dans la polarisation. Avec des IA comme Deep Seek, on peut espérer des espaces de discussion plus équilibrés à l’avenir.

  22. The article shows how media deepens polarization, but tools like chat gpt can work differently. If used openly, ChatGPT Nederlands offers balanced views and breaks echo chambers—but if used only to confirm biases, it risks repeating the same cycle.

  23. 我們KaoGuTi有很多IT專業人士,我們提供的考試練習題和答案是由很多IT精英認證的。我們KaoGuTi提供的考試練習題和答案覆蓋面相當大,正確率可達100%。雖然有很多類似網站,也許他們可以為你提供學習指南以及線上服務,但我們KaoGuTi是領先這些眾多網站的。能使KaoGuTi在這麼多同行中脫穎而出的原因是我們有相當準確確命中考題的考試練習題和答案以及可以對考試練習題和答案迅速的更新。這樣可以很好的提高通過率,讓準備參加SAP C_THR86_2505認證考試的人更安心地選擇使用KaoGuTi為你提供的考試練習題和答案通過考試。我們KaoGuTi 100%保證你通過SAP C_THR86_2505認證考試

  24. Insightful post on how media and new communication tech have fueled political polarization. It’s interesting to see parallels with tools like Chat GPT-while they expand access to information, they also highlight the need for balance to avoid reinforcing echo chambers.

  25. This article on polarization highlights how media and technology shaped modern politics, amplifying division and echo chambers. It actually makes me think of soundboard unblocked platforms—just like they give you instant, unfiltered access to sounds without barriers, today’s media gives audiences direct, often unfiltered channels. Both show how easy access can empower expression but also intensify extremes depending on how it’s used.

  26. 試験の知識が豊富な専門家によってコンパイルされた4A0-100試験トレントをすべての受験者に提供し、4A0-100学習教材のコンパイルの経験が豊富です。最新バージョンを入手したら、できるだけ早くメールボックスに送信します。 4A0-100試験問題では、学生が練習に20〜30時間を費やすだけで4A0-100試験に合格する自信が持てるので、一部の労働者にとっては非常に便利です。 4A0-100試験に合格して目標を達成するための最良のツールでなければなりません。

  27. HPE6-A88試験問題の99%の合格率を確保できます。 HPE6-A88学習ガイドを使用すると、HPE6-A88試験に合格できます。そして、HPはあなたが想像できる正しいことです。必ずHPE6-A88認定を希望します。そこで、HPE6-A88試験資料と同じくらい優れたツールを使用して、わずか20〜30時間勉強して練習してから試験に合格してみませんか。さまざまなバージョンのHPE Aruba Networking ClearPass Exam試験ブレーンダンプを使用すると、いつでもどこでも勉強と練習ができます。

  28. Itcertkr 에서 출시한Cisco인증350-701 덤프는Cisco인증350-701 실제시험의 출제범위와 출제유형을 대비하여 제작된 최신버전 덤프입니다. 시험문제가 바뀌면 제일 빠른 시일내에 덤프를 업데이트 하도록 최선을 다하고 있으며 1년 무료 업데이트서비스를 제공해드립니다. 1년 무료 업데이트서비스를 제공해드리기에 시험시간을 늦추어도 시험성적에 아무런 페를 끼치지 않습니다. Itcertkr에 믿음을 느낄수 있도록 구매사이트마다 무료샘플 다운가능기능을 설치하였습니다.무료샘플을 체험해보시고Itcertkr을 선택해주세요.

  29. Wenn Sie sich um die PMI CAPM-German Zertifizierungsprüfung bemühen, kann Fast2test Ihnen helfen, Ihren Traum zu verwirklichen. Die Übungen zur PMI CAPM-German Zertifizierungsprüfung werden von der Praxis prüft. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur PMI CAPM-German Zertifizierungsprüfung sind von guter Qualität, die Ihnen helfen, die PMI CAPM-German Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen und ein IT-Expert zu werden.

  30. By reading this article, I’ve developed a new understanding of both my work and life. I earned my promotion and salary increase with the Exam topics PRINCE2-Foundation pdf. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you all early promotions!

  31. Die echten und originalen Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zu NCP-US-6.5 Zertifizierung (Nutanix Certified Professional – Unified Storage (NCP-US) v6.5) bei ZertPruefung wurden verfasst von unseren IT-Experten mit den Informationen von NCP-US-6.5 Prüfungen (Nutanix Certified Professional – Unified Storage (NCP-US) v6.5) aus dem Testcenter wie PROMETRIC oder VUE.

  32. 雖然有其他的線上Salesforce的MC-101考試培訓資源在市場上,但我們Fast2test Salesforce的MC-101考試培訓資料是最好的。因為我們會定期更新,始終提供準確的Salesforce的MC-101考試認證資料,我們Fast2test Salesforce的MC-101考試培訓資料提供一年的免費更新,你會得到最新的更新了的Fast2test Salesforce的MC-101考試培訓資料。

  33. I can’t express how much I appreciate your article, it was truly memorable. Don’t miss the free New NS0-528 exam sims questions—the key to promotion and higher pay!

  34. C-THR81-2505試験問題は正式に認定されています。 私たちSAPの目標は、効率的な学習スタイルで、SAP Certified Associate – SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Core関連するC-THR81-2505試験に合格できるようにすることです。 C-THR81-2505トレーニング資料の品質と手頃な価格により、当社の競争力は常に世界のリーダーです。 C-THR81-2505学習教材は、他のトレーニング教材よりも高い合格率を持っているため、完全な結果を得ることができると確信しています。 C-THR81-2505試験問題を使用すると、Pass4Test成功が保証されます。

  35. I appreciate the inspiration this article provides, thanks for sharing! This Valid CSPAI test collection materials helped me get a promotion and salary increase. Now it’s free to all. Hope you achieve your career goals!

  36. DeutschPrüfung ist eine Website, die alle IT-Lerner wissen. DeutschPrüfung ist von den IT-Zertifizungskandidaten immer gut bewertet. Es ist eine Website, die Leuten wirklich helfen kann, weil DeutschPrüfung eine IT-Elitengruppen hat und auch die ausgezeichneten und echten Prüfungsmaterialien zur Amazon SAP-C02 Zertifizierungsprüfung anbietet. Deshalb kann DeutschPrüfung anderen viele nützliche Schulungsunterlagen über SAP-C02 Prüfung bereitstellen, die ihre Bedürfnisse abdecken.

  37. This article is a true inspiration, thank you for sharing it! The 1Z0-1160-1 detail explanation helped me climb the career ladder and earn a raise. Now, I’m sharing it for free with all of you. Wishing you success!

  38. The article is truly inspiring, thank you for sharing! This Reliable C-TS422-2023 test cram helped me move up in my career. Now it’s free for everyone. Hope you all reach your promotions soon!

  39. The article is very well written, and I have learned a lot from it. The New MB-500 test passing score questions are free—use them to elevate your career and salary!

  40. 在生活中我們不要不要總是要求別人給我什麼,要想我能為別人做什麼。工作中你能為老闆創造很大的價值,老闆當然在乎你的職位,包括薪水。一樣的道理,如果我們一直屈服於一個簡單的IT職員,遲早會被淘汰,我們應該努力通過IT認證,一步一步走到最高層,VCESoft HP的HPE7-J02考試認證的練習題及答可以幫助我們快捷方便的通往成功的道路,而且享受保障政策,已經有很多IT人士在行動了,就在VCESoft HP的HPE7-J02考試培訓資料,當然不會錯過。

Leave a Reply to Mike Scott Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *