what is political is not always civil

In this week’s readings, Castells writes about world powers changing as they are challenged by globalization, deregulation, and today’s “crisis of political legitimacy” (2007). Certainly the access to information provided by the internet, and more recently the influence of mobile internet access, has changed some societies. While the internet can neither be blamed nor praised for the fall of dictators as of late, it can certainly be lauded for its part. Tufekci and Wilson explore this future in their piece on the protests in Tahrir Square during the political upheaval in Egypt in 2011. As an American who has never known anything other than freedom of speech, it really hit me that “for many people, the online sphere might have been the only context in which they encountered dissident content” (2012). While they did find that traditional face-to-face exchange was effective in spreading the word about protests, the information presented about the behavior of those present as citizen journalists was intriguing. Digital media and mobile phones were allowing citizens, potentially participating in political protest for the first time, to post real time documentation of the events. Although not mentioned in their article, I would like to read some research on empowerment of individuals who have cameras connected directly to the internet. Does having the ability to share what is happening around them embolden them to take actions they wouldn’t otherwise?

Mobile internet has produced something of a third eye for all of us. We can now access in a moment what we used to either have to memorize or look up later. With a mobile phone, nothing has to be out of sight, out of mind. However, what is on our mind is influenced by “old media”. The 24 hour news machine still influences what is on our collective minds. Sandy is the obvious example this week, and we’ve even been caught up in fake Instagrams of Sandy’s destruction. http://mashable.com/2012/10/29/fake-hurricane-sandy-photos/. Castells reiterates this point again citing, “What does not exist in the media does not exist in the public mind” (2007). However, with these faked images of Sandy, and other internet entities going viral, aren’t we taking part in this creation of what is on the collective societal mind?

At the heart of our readings these past two weeks has been one main question, does the internet affect our engagement in the civil/political process? We may have lowered the cost of accessing political information, but it still seems that those who are utilizing the internet for political knowledge or participation are those that would have sought it out regardless. Wilson confirms this by quoting Coleman, “Political participation is to a large extent driven by affective motives” (2004). Even those who do have genuine interest in the political process and seek to engage in political interaction online tend to lose their civility in the process. In their piece, Loveland and Popescu concluded that, “Online interaction is thus less prone to be polite, which could also explain the lack of positive reinforcement” (2011). Is it any wonder that those of us who aren’t particularly interested in politics are driven further away from the polls as we are exposed to callous exchanges both on TV and the internet by those that are engaged in the process?

19 thoughts on “what is political is not always civil

  1. That is an interesting question about whether or not cameras connected to the internet embolden individuals to do things that they would normally not do. I certainly think that it could.

  2. 경쟁이 치열한 IT업계에서 굳굳한 자신만의 자리를 찾으려면 국제적으로 인정받는 IT자격증 취득은 너무나도 필요합니다. Cisco인증 200-201시험은 IT인사들중에서 뜨거운 인기를 누리고 있습니다. ExamPassdump는 IT인증시험에 대비한 시험전 공부자료를 제공해드리는 전문적인 사이트입니다.한방에 쉽게Cisco인증 200-201시험에서 고득점으로 패스하고 싶다면ExamPassdump의Cisco인증 200-201덤프를 선택하세요.저렴한 가격에 비해 너무나도 높은 시험적중율과 시험패스율, 언제나 여러분을 위해 최선을 다하는ExamPassdump가 되겠습니다.

  3. I’m truly amazed by this article, thank you for sharing it. This JN0-280 valid test certification cost helped me get promoted and receive a salary increase. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you success in your career journey!

  4. This article is wonderfully written, and I’ve learned many useful techniques from it. We’re providing JN0-105 dump check, packed with valuable resources, for free, to help you.

  5. Such an inspiring read, thank you for sharing this! This Exam 300-810 passing score helped me achieve career growth with a promotion and salary raise. It’s free now for everyone. Wishing you success!

  6. The content of the article is thought-provoking, and I’ve learned a lot from it. The ANC-201 latest exam cram content is great, and you can enjoy it at no expense.

  7. GAQMPDFバージョン、PCバージョン、APPオンラインバージョンなど、3つの異なるバージョンのCertified Forensic Analyst (CFA) prepトレントを選択できます。 異なるバージョンには独自の利点とユーザー数があります。PDFバージョンの機能をご紹介します。 CertJukenのCFA-001試験トレントのPDFは、主にデモの利便性のために、若者の間で最も一般的なバージョンであることに疑いの余地はありません。Certified Forensic Analyst (CFA) 印刷してメモを取ることができます。

  8. Thank you for bringing such an extraordinary article! The HP2-I57 valid dumps free questions are available for free. Wishing you the best of luck in your exams!

  9. I’m grateful for your article, it truly made an impact on me. The Valid test SIE objectives pdf exam questions are crucial for promotion and salary growth—get them for free!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *