Open Access, expanding the Share button

 I admit that even the idea of open access was counter-intuitive for me before this week’s readings. Coming from an academic background that valued copyright, publishing laws, and intellectual property above all else, it felt wrong to me for anyone to suggest we not only give away our work for free but we encourage others to modify it as well. I tried as much as possible to come into the readings with an open mind and to explore the existing and potential benefits that come with open access.

 In his piece Open Source as Culture/Culture as Open Source from The Social Media Reader, Vaidhyanathan was straight forward about the benefits of open source as opposed to the short falls of copyright. He lists peer production and the long standing norm of sharing new discoveries with one another openly as selling points for open access.  Peer production exemplifies the old adage that two heads are better than one, and sharing the product/idea/service developed from this collaboration through open access can benefit anyone or everyone.  Previously I had not given much thought to how new and counter-productive copyright law can be. I had always come from the perspective that copyright was there to protect the artist’s ability to support themselves on their work, not that copyright could actually hinder information sources. Not to say that copyright is inherently bad, but most circumstances could be served by a middle ground. Vaidhyanathan confirms this by stating, “Most important, these experiments and projects show that “all rights reserved” need not be the default state of copyright protection. For many people, “some rights reserved” serves the interests of creators better than the absolutist proprietary model does.”

With peer production and collaboration established as strengths of open access, what could a potential risk be? When there are multiple people involved in the same project, it is not always guaranteed that they will have a common objective. Who is to say that the next person to modify an existing idea, object, or service is making it better or even has positive intentions with their actions? The authors of chapter 5 in The Social Media Reader narrate an incident when Stephen Colbert purposefully edited a Wikipedia article with false information and encouraged the viewers of his show, The Colbert Report, to do the same. Wikipedia had fail safes in place to eventually correct the article, but the situation did bring to light the understanding that some kind of regulation is essential to maintain the integrity of a project that makes use of collaboration.

I asked for a different view than my own on intellectual property, and Mandiberg‘s Giving Things Away Is Hard Work was certain there to provide. Practice over origin was the overarching theme, and patent is thrown by the wayside for the good of the community. He goes as far as hoping that a large bike manufacturer will steal one of his inventions just so it reaches a larger audience. While I did feel that his philosophy on giving away your work for free was somewhat unrealistic for most workers in today’s world, I did agree with his point on how the participatory nature of open access can be the genesis of a community. He writes, “The sharing of the project creates participation. And participation is at the edge of the beginnings of community.” 

Because this is my first M.A. class, I had not given much thought previously to the cost of academic publishing. However, while the prior readings had not really sold me on open access, Dawson’s DIY Academy from The Social Media Reader coupled with the first chapter of the Open Access textbook have showed me how flawed the current publishing system in academia can be with respect to cost barriers and influence of the public and publisher on the subjects explored by authors. Open access has obvious strengths in this area because publishing online can be done practically free, the material can be accessed by anyone so there is no pressure to cover a subject of interest to a publisher’s market. While online publishing may not now have the same integrity as an established printed publication has built over time, I believe that the academic world will come up with a change out of necessity, and very soon. However, the irony that only part of the Open Access textbook was available online for free was not lost on me.

68 thoughts on “Open Access, expanding the Share button

  1. Colbert’s critique of “Wikiality” is a very interesting point to consider from the readings. It questions the fundamental “truths” that govern our reality by interrogating the accuracy of how we record and chronicle our history as a species. The question of truth as it relates to the present moment always brings to mind the movie Memento in which the main character recreates his identity by analyzing notes from his past. Everyday, he remakes himself dependent on new information and it just so happens he is willingly deceiving himself in the process.

  2. 21世紀は情報の世紀です。 そのため、SAPのC-ARSUM-2404試験問題のフィールドには多くの変更があります。 彼らはまた、人々の生活と人間社会の運営方法を大きく変えています。 C-ARSUM-2404試験の準備をしている場合、弊社Xhs1991はこのWebサイトで最高の電子C-ARSUM-2404試験トレントを提供できます。 私たちのC-ARSUM-2404のSAP Certified Associate – Implementation Consultant – SAP Ariba Supplier Managementテストトレントの指導の下で、あなたはトラブルを回避し、すべてをあなたの歩みに乗せることができると強く信じています。

  3. Thank you for your article, it gave me such a fresh perspective. Here’s the Pass4sure DEX-403 exam prep test that led to my promotion and salary raise. It’s available for free today for all—wishing you success in your career!

  4. どのようにして短時間で試験に合格し、証明書を取得できますか? ANVE-JPN試験トレントは、目標を達成するための最良の選択です。お客様のニーズに応じて、当社の製品は多くの専門家によって改訂されました。 ANVE-JPN試験問題集のほとんどの機能は、お客様がより多くの時間を節約し、お客様をリラックスさせるのに役立ちます。 ANVE-JPNテストクイズを使用することを選択した場合、短時間でANVE-JPN試験に合格することは非常に簡単です。 ANVE-JPN試験問題の勉強に20〜30時間費やすだけです。他のことをする自由時間が増えます。

  5. Can’t stop myself from liking this amazing content. This is the 2V0-31.24 Free Dumps test that helped me with my career progression and salary increase, and it’s available to you for free today. Wishing you success in your career!

  6. This is so good, I’m liking it without a doubt. With free access to Latest test guide HQT-4420 files, you can explore its rich content to help you succeed.

  7. That piece really enriched my understanding. We offer free access to CRT-261 reliable test duration, filled with material meant to help you succeed.

  8. This article is truly one worth keeping and referring to. Thanks to the IIA-CIA-Part1 latest real test, I was able to earn a promotion and raise. It’s now free to all. Wishing you all the best for your promotion!

  9. I’m in awe of the quality of your article, thank you for sharing it! I’m sharing the H12-821_V1.0-ENU latest test camp file questions that helped me achieve my promotion and raise—get them for free today!

  10. This article is nothing short of spectacular, thank you for sharing. C_C4H41_2405 valid practice exam fee offers detailed and free content, aimed at assisting you with your goals.

  11. Your article was a breath of fresh air, thank you for sharing it. Sharing C_TS462_2023 reliable exam question materials for free—boost your career with these essential resources!

  12. I appreciate you sharing this article, it’s very inspiring! New A00-255 test certification cost offers great value, and the content is completely free.

  13. The article is easy to understand, and I have benefited a lot from it. Here’s the C_S4CPR_2408 cert guide exam that boosted my career with a promotion and salary increase. It’s free today for all! Wishing you success in your career journey.

  14. I’m deeply impressed by this article, thank you for your share. The Accurate CIPP-E study material questions are now free! Wishing you success in your exams!

  15. I’m grateful for your article, it truly stood out to me. Enhance your IT knowledge—free New CTFL-AT exam labs shared! Wishing you success!

  16. I’m so thankful for your article, it was a real game-changer. Here’s the free Latest 100-160 exam vce free material! Wishing everyone good luck on their exams!

  17. Such a fantastic article, I’m grateful for your generosity in sharing. C1000-130 Free download offers detailed content free of charge to help you in your learning journey.

  18. Your article is exceptional, thank you for sharing! The Certification AI-900 exam cost questions are free—unlock career success and salary raises today!

  19. Your article is brilliant beyond words, I’m thankful for your share! Good luck on your exam! Free KCNA pass test guide study guides here.

  20. Sind Sie IT-Fachmann? Wollen Sie Erfolg? Dann kaufen Sie die Schulungsunterlagen zur Salesforce Financial-Services-Cloud Zertifizierungsprüfung von PrüfungFrage. Sie werden von der Praxis prüft. Sie werden Ihnen helfen, die Salesforce Financial-Services-Cloud Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen. Ihre Berufsaussichten werden sich sicher verbessern. Sie werden ein hohes Gehalt beziehen. Sie können eine Karriere in der internationalen Gesellschaft machen. Wenn Sie spitze technischen Fähigkeiten haben, sollen Sie sich keine Sorgen machen. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur Salesforce Financial-Services-Cloud Zertifizierungsprüfung von PrüfungFrage werden Ihren Traum verwirklichen. Wir werden mit Ihnen durch dick und dünn gehen und die Herausforderung mit Ihnen zusammen nehmen.

  21. Ohne Zeitaufwand und Anstrengung die Netskope NSK300 Prüfung zu bestehen ist unmöglich, daher bemühen wir uns darum, Ihre Belastung der Vorbereitung auf Netskope NSK300 zu erleichtern. Standardisierte Simulierungsrüfung und die leicht zu verstehende Erläuterungen können Ihnen helfen, allmählich die Methode für Netskope NSK300 Prüfung zu beherrschen. Um mehr Stress von Ihnen zu beseitigen versprechen wir, falls Sie die Prüfung nicht bestehen, geben wir Ihnen volle Rückerstattung der Netskope NSK300 Prüfungsunterlagen nach der Überprüfung Ihres Zeugnisses. ExamFragen ist vertrauenswüdig!

  22. I’m deeply moved by your article, thank you for sharing this insight! Here’s the free Latest test MLO braindumps material! Wishing everyone good luck on their exams!

  23. I’m in total awe of your article, thank you for letting us read it! Free 300-215 valid test sample questions shared to elevate your IT skills. Wishing you success in your exams!

  24. Liking it because this content is awesome. This DCPLA valid test vce set helped me climb the career ladder and get a salary raise. Now, it’s available for free to all. Wishing you all the best in your professional growth!

  25. It offered a wealth of insights I hadn’t considered before. GEIR free practice test exam provides a range of useful materials for free, hoping they help you progress.

  26. ITZert ist eine gute Website, die effiziente Ausbildung zur Avaya 77202T Zertifizierungsprüfung bietet. Und ITZert verspricht, dass Sie die Avaya 77202T Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen können. Sonst geben wir Ihnen eine volle Rückerstattung. Vorm Kauf unserer Produkte können Sie im Internet teilweise die Demo zur Avaya 77202T Zertifizierungsprüfung von ITZert kostenlos herunterladen. Dann werden Sie mehr Vertrauen in unsere Prodzkte setzen. Sie können sich dann gut auf Ihre Avaya 77202T Zertifizierungsprüfung vorbereiten.

  27. The article is very well written, and I have learned a lot from it. I’m offering the Latest C_THR88_2505 test guide test that played a key role in my promotion and salary increase. It’s available for free today—good luck with your career journey!

  28. Thank you for sharing this remarkable article, it truly impressed me. The material in 312-50 valid test book is extensive and offered freely to support your learning goals.

  29. VCESoft Palo Alto Networks的XSOAR-Engineer考試培訓資料是所有的互聯網培訓資源裏最頂尖的培訓資料,我們的知名度度是很高的,這都是許多考生利用了VCESoft Palo Alto Networks的XSOAR-Engineer考試培訓資料所得到的成果,如果你也使用我們VCESoft Palo Alto Networks的XSOAR-Engineer考試培訓資料,我們可以給你100%成功的保障,若是沒有通過,我們將保證退還全部購買費用,為了廣大考生的切身利益,我們VCESoft絕對是信的過的。

  30. Your article is truly outstanding, thank you for sharing it with us! Thanks to the CCSK latest practice materials, I was able to earn a promotion and raise. It’s now free to all. Wishing you all the best for your promotion!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *